Co-owners Paul DiAgostino (above) and Gino Vitale bought the 63-year-old Brooklyn pizzeria in 2004.

House of Pizza & Calzone continues tradition, expands organically

Expectations run high with a sign that reads “The famous House of Pizza & Calzone” above the pizzeria’s entrance in South Brooklyn, New York.

Paul DiAgostino and Gino Vitale bought House of Pizza in 2004, but this slice house had a treasured history long before the two came into the picture.

The Back Story

House of Pizza & Calzone has stood on Union Street in Brooklyn since the 1950s. The pizzeria, originally named Simone’s, opened in 1952. Shortly after, two Italian immigrant friends (Giovanni and Onofrio) who worked at the shop purchased it and changed its name.

In the beginning, House of Pizza & Calzone served traditional New York-style pizza slices with two options — sausage or mushroom — and fried calzones (a hit with the working-class neighborhood and the shore men from the Columbia waterfront shipping ports). Fried calzones were, and still are, unique. The two friends brought the frying technique from the Apuglia region of southern Italy. “They had a huge wok and they would turn them with drumsticks,” DiAgostino says.

The slice shop’s popularity grew, becoming a neighborhood mainstay through the years. Giovanni and Onofrio continued to own and operate House of Pizza & Calzone until they sold the business to DiAgostino and Vitale in the 2000s.

A New Era

DiAgostino and Vitale were well aware of the House of Pizza & Calzone before the purchase. When it became available, they jumped at the opportunity, though decades of established loyalty in the neighborhood put a lot of pressure on the new owners, DiAgostino says. “When you come into an establishment that has been here so long, our fear was what can we change and what do we have to keep the same,” he says, “People don’t like change. The biggest challenge, I think, was overcoming the tag of being the next guy or not the original guy. It was definitely our fear in the beginning.”

When DiAgostino and Vitale took over the business, having the original recipes aided them in gaining neighborhood acceptance. “We weren’t sure how much they were going to pass over to us,” DiAgostino says of the original recipes. “So one day just having a conversation, I ask them, ‘Are you willing to give us your recipes?’ He was touched by it. He thought we just wanted to come in and ‘get out of the way, it’s our turn.’ What they did here for 50 years worked. Why change it?”

And House of Pizza & Calzone continued as it was for a few years with DiAgostino and Vitale’s minor additions and personal touches. That was until, DiAgostino says, they kept hitting obstacles when they needed to make repairs on the hundred-year-old building. “All of the plumbing, electrical, HVAC, a lot of stuff was just old and outdated,” he says. “When you called the trades to come out and look at it, they would go, ‘there is nothing to do here, you got to take it out.’”

The pizzeria was tiny with only four tables, mainly a pickup window and counter service. Coupling the size with maintenance issues, the owners gutted the space for a total renovation in 2008. The construction was done in just five short weeks thanks to Vitale’s background in the construction and real estate industries. They opened up the back of the store to add a dining room and outdoor seating, which combined seats 50.

The remodel was completed to showcase reclaimed neighborhood materials including brick walls, a tin ceiling and wood floors and beams.

A face lift to the exterior features sliding windows. A large block of salvaged wood sits atop vertical steel beams. “We wanted to go for the look of the steel and the wood, which is more working class,” DiAgostino says.

One showpiece of the entrance is a throwback hand-painted sign.

With the expansion, House of Pizza & Calzone also broadened its menu with more pizza options, as well as sandwiches, panini, pastas and deserts.

In addition to the original-recipe, New York-style pizza, the pizzeria has also received acclaim for its Sicilian Pizza. A crowd favorite is the Upside-Down, pan-baked thick crust pizza layered with fresh mozzarella on the bottom and topped with tomato sauce, and finished with grated Romano cheese and olive oil ($25). The Grandma’s Pizza has a huge following — a thin crust, pan-baked pizza with a whole peeled tomato sauce made with garlic and basil and topped with mozzarella ($18).

The 60-year-old calzone recipe has remained the same — pocket-shaped dough stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella and ham, and deep-fried until crispy golden brown ($5.50).

A testament to their efforts to pay homage to the previous owners happens every Saturday. “People who were born and raised here, even the ones who no longer live here, they hold that loyalty,” DiAgostino says. “Saturday, we call it “pilgrimage day” because they all tend to congregate in the same places here that still exist from when they were kids.

The previous owners, who DiAgostino refers to as the old timers, still drop by the restaurant, too.

The Next Step

In the coming months, the House of Pizza & Calzone is set to add a full-service component to the counter business. “We both decided the next natural step is to take what we got and offer more along the lines of family dining,” DiAgostino says. “Good food at good prices and just put it out there everyday on a consistent level.”
DiAgostino says they’ve added a full-sized prep kitchen in the basement and a display kitchen in the dining area in the back of the restaurant, featuring a wood-fired oven. He wasn’t ready to divulge what style of pizza, but he hinted about the concept’s direction. “The slice business is something that I always want to keep,” he says, adding that the full-service kitchen will operate at night.

Denise Greer is associate editor at Pizza Today.