We ranked the Top 20 Pizzerias in America of 2024 based on appearances on national and international pizza lists

As 2024 draws to a close let’s look the Top 20 Pizzerias that made the most national and international pizza lists in 2024. Each year we compile the top pizza lists in the U.S. to create our Guide to the 2024 Best Pizza Lists. With assistance of Jasper AI, I combed through the lists to find out which pizzerias were the highest rated that made the most lists. I sought to find out which pizzerias were ranked the most in national best pizza lists we shared in our Guide to the 2024 Best Pizza Lists.

All of the 2024 lists used different criteria for their selections. Some based the best pizza list on customer reviews or voting, while others used an expert panel of judges. Take a spin through the Guide linked above to find out more about each best pizza list’s ranking criteria.

Best of the Best Top 20 Pizzerias in America best on our Guide to the 2024 Best Pizza Lists.

Check out the follow Best of the Best Top 20 Pizzerias in the U.S. that have garnered a plethora of national and international attention for their pizza.

1. Pequod’s Pizzeria – Chicago, Illinois
2. Tony’s Pizza Napoletan – San Francisco, California
3.  L’Industrie Pizzeria – New York, New York
4. Una Pizza Napoletana  – New York, New York
5. Pizzeria Beddia – Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
6. Ribalta – New York, New York
7. Razza Pizza Artigianale – Jersey City, New Jersey
8. Ken’s Artisan Pizza – Portland, Oregon
9. Don Antonio – New York, New York
10. Robert’s Pizza – Chicago, Illinois
11. Song’ E Napule – New York, New York
12. Kesté Pizza & Vino – New York, New York
    
13. Inferno Pizzeria Napoletana – Darnestown, Maryland
14. Spacca Napoli Pizzeria – Chicago, Illinois
15. Flour House – San Luis Obispo, California
16. Mission Pizza Napoletana – Winston-Salem, North Carolina
17. Fabrica Pizza – Tampa, Florida
18. Pizza Rock – Las Vegas, Nevada
19. Pizzeria Bianco – Phoenix, Arizona
20. Modern Apizza – New Haven, Connecticut

But we didn’t stop there. We wanted to see which American cities were home to the most America’s top rated pizzerias.

Top 10 Cities with Top Ranked Pizzerias

The following cities garnered the most pizzerias ranked in our Guide to the 2024 Best Pizza Lists, that showcases national and international best pizza lists:

1. New York, New York
2. Chicago, Illinois
3. San Francisco, California
4. Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
5. Las Vegas, Nevada
6. Portland, Oregon
7. Phoenix, Arizona
8. Los Angeles, California
9. New Haven, Connecticut
10. Jersey City, New Jersey

As you plan your 2025 pizzeria visits and pizza tours, consider the above pizzerias and cities.

Go to our Guide to the 2024 Best Pizza Lists to see if your pizzeria made a national or international best pizza list in 2024.

* Some analysis was compiled with the use of AI. “This content has been created by an AI language model and is intended to provide general information. We do not assume any responsibility or liability for the use or interpretation of this content.”

Check out the latest pizza trends, hot pizza styles, top pizza toppings, pizzeria labor market, restaurant marketing and pizza industry insights in our 2025 Pizza Industry Trends Report.